Today I realized I've been doing this all wrong.
Ok, maybe not
all wrong.
First -- a little about what I've done right (right until further notice anyway). I've learned a lot in the last couple of months from all of the research I've been doing.
When working out companion planting plans, I've found it much easier to prioritize what you know you want most and plan around it. I know Spot wants strawberries, so that was a top priority. Looking up strawberries, I learned that, not only are they a great thing to grow in this region, but they need good drainage, so I picked out a light-appropriate, drainable place for them on the slope adjacent to the pear tree.
Next, I looked up what strawberries like in my library copy of
Carrots Love Tomatoes (Riotte), and learn that, among others, strawberries like bush beans (nitrogen), lettuce (as a border -- reason unknown), and chysanthemums (pest control). I also learn that all these plants are succeptable to aphids.
So what controls aphids?
Carrots Love Tomatoes says ladybugs eat aphids, but it doesn't say what ladybugs like. Over to
Gaia's Garden (Hemenway) for a list of host plants for beneficial insects. Among many others: yarrow and fennel. I remembered seeing fennel and yarrow in a list together somewhere before, and then realized that they are both in the apple tree guild (same book) which can be used for any fruit tree -- like the pear tree that's right next to the strawberries. I drew up my plans to plant fennel, yarrow, comfrey, and artichoke around the pear tree. AND, for mulch on the strawberries and their companions, I can use pine needles from the pine trees in my front yard.
At this point I'm feeling pretty slick.
I assembled a couple more lists of companion plants and selected locations for them. I was disappointed to learn from
Roses Love Garlic (Riotte) that western columbine will not grow well with honeysuckle. I had elaborate plans for a bi-level, fenceline arbor that grew columbine and honeysuckle on top (both native and loved by hummingbirds -- found this out on the Washington Native Plant Society website) and a monster grapevine on the second level. Alas, a western columbine is a solitary creature and does not play well with others. Off to zone 4 with it. Will the honeysuckle smother the grapevine? I hope not.
Plant lists and vague notions of location in hand, I decided to redraw the fruit and veggie patch of my master plan in more detail. Looking out my bedroom window at the area of the yard that I am drawing, I started fantsizing about removing the grass and replacing it with one of the other types of gardens that I want to fit in somewhere -- tea garden, butterfly garden, cosmetics garden -- maybe all the same thing -- but I couldn't imagine a way to make it look good. And then I realized my mistake -- I was trying to figure out how to work this all in and the paths that we'll need without ruining the lines on the property. All along I had been trying to work with the design of the existing lines and pathways that, to my sensibility, don't follow the contours of the land or suit our purposes. The previous owner sectioned off the land into three parts a fairly linear fashion so that they could keep their dogs in the lower half by the stream (remember the doghouse?). The existing lines are nice enough, but they don't work for what we are trying to do. I'm not the greatest visual designer, but even I knew it would be ugly with the new plantings.
Changing the design of the lines in the yard changes where we plant things, and spoils a good chunk of my clever planning. So, it's not a complete do-over, more of a mulligan, but I think we'll be much happier with the evolution of the land if we get the foundational lines right from the start.
Sigh.
In other news, I got tired of wearing scanty garden clogs in the mud and worrying about getting muck on my shoes, so I got a pair of mud boots. Cute hey?

Somewhere a real permaculturalist is weeping.